In 1949 nine women of the Arthur Murray Girls baseball team took the field against the all-male squad from the Patchogue Athletics. By that year, the Murrays had been together as a semi-pro outfit for some time. Formed out of the sandlots and playgrounds of Queens, they grew under the tutelage of New York Times sportswriter Mike Strauss to become the nucleus of a league that by the late 1940s became the American Girls Baseball Conference.

On today’s episode, historian and Suffolk County Community College librarian Fabio Montella presents his research into the Murrays, their game with Patchogue, and their full, storied history. Although based out of Cedarhurst in Nassau County, the women traveled a loop that saw them taking the field against the likes of the Glen Cove Clovers, the Perth Amboy Cardinalettes, and the Stamford Nutmegs. Fabio also introduces us to Gloria Del Percio, the last living member of the Arthur Murray Girls.

The story of 20th century women’s baseball has been popularized by the movie A League of Their Own but women had their own leagues across the country. The Murray Girls encapsulate that story at the local level, both as a team and as individual women who loved to play the game.

Further Research

• The Arthur Murray Girls circa 1953 (Getty Images)
• “Girls’ Nine Next Opponent for A’s.” (Patchogue Advance)
• “Recognizing an Unsung Women’s Baseball Hero” (LI Herald)
• Audio Footnotes
  • The Cuban Giants of Long Island
  • Satchel Paige in Riverhead